Empire Home Protect vs Old Republic Home Protection (2026)
Key Takeaways
- Empire Home Protect offers home warranty coverage to homeowners across the United States, while Old Republic Home Protection sells in 25 states plus Washington, D.C.
- Old Republic uses three set tiers (Basic, Deluxe, Elite) priced roughly $45 to $90 per month, with a $100 or $125 service fee per claim.
- Old Republic caps heating and air conditioning at $6,500 each and appliances at $3,500 to $7,000, depending on the plan tier you choose.
- Both companies cover major systems and appliances that fail from normal wear and tear and both back completed repairs for 30 days.
- The right plan depends on where you live, your home’s age, and which systems you most want protected, so compare caps and fees before you buy.
Choosing between Empire Home Protect and Old Republic Home Protection comes down to coverage area, plan flexibility, service fees, and payout caps. Empire Home Protect provides home warranty plans to homeowners across the United States and lets you match coverage to your home’s systems and appliances. Old Republic Home Protection is a long-established home warranty provider that sells three fixed plan tiers in 25 states and Washington, D.C. This 2026 comparison lays out how the two stack up on price structure, coverage limits, availability, and the claim experience so you can pick the plan that fits your home.
Empire Home Protect vs Old Republic: Quick Comparison
Empire Home Protect and Old Republic Home Protection are both service contracts that help pay to repair or replace major home systems and appliances when they break down from everyday use. The table below compares the two on the factors homeowners weigh most: where each is sold, how plans are priced, service fees, coverage caps, and the repair guarantee.
| Factor | Empire Home Protect | Old Republic Home Protection |
|---|---|---|
| Availability | Homeowners across the United States | 25 states + Washington, D.C. |
| Plan structure | Plans built around major systems and appliances | 3 fixed tiers: Basic, Deluxe, Elite |
| Typical monthly price | Varies by home and plan — see your quote | $45 to $90 per month |
| Service fee per claim | Set at enrollment | $100 or $125 |
| Heating / cooling caps | Stated in your plan contract | $6,500 each |
| Appliance caps | Stated in your plan contract | $3,500 to $7,000 per appliance |
| Repair guarantee | 30 days on completed covered repairs | 30 days |
How Old Republic Home Protection Plans Work
Old Republic Home Protection is a home warranty company that sells three comprehensive tiers and charges a flat service fee each time a technician is dispatched for a covered claim. According to NerdWallet’s 2026 review, monthly prices run about $45 to $90 and a full year can be paid over three months.
The three tiers add coverage as you move up:
- Basic ($45 to $55 per month): appliances, plumbing, electrical, and miscellaneous items such as the garage door opener and central vacuum. Heating and cooling are not included at this tier.
- Deluxe ($55 to $70 per month): adds HVAC (heating, air conditioning, ductwork), a washer and dryer set, faucets, and garage door springs.
- Elite ($70 to $90 per month): adds a pre-season HVAC tune-up and raises the per-appliance cap to $7,000.
Payout caps matter: Old Republic limits heating at $6,500 and air conditioning at $6,500, with appliances capped at $3,500 per item on Basic and Deluxe or $7,000 on Elite. Interior electrical and general plumbing carry no stated dollar limit.
How Does Empire Home Protect Compare?
Empire Home Protect is a home warranty provider whose plans cover repair or replacement of major systems and appliances that fail from normal wear and tear, available to homeowners across the United States. The biggest practical difference is reach and flexibility: Empire Home Protect serves homeowners nationwide rather than a 25-state footprint, and coverage is provided under a plan you match to your home instead of three fixed tiers.
With Empire Home Protect, a covered repair is carried out by an independent, vetted service technician, and your plan helps cover the cost of the parts and labor spelled out in your contract. Completed covered repairs are backed for 30 days, the same guarantee window Old Republic offers. To see exact pricing, caps, and the service fee for your home, request a free quote or review the available home warranty plans.
Which Home Warranty Is Right for You?
The better home warranty is the one whose coverage area, caps, and fees match your situation. If you live outside Old Republic’s 25-state footprint, Empire Home Protect is the practical choice because coverage is available to homeowners nationwide. If you are inside that footprint, compare the numbers that affect your wallet.
Use these questions to decide:
- Where is your home? Old Republic sells in 25 states plus D.C.; Empire Home Protect serves homeowners across the country.
- How old is your HVAC? If heating or cooling is likely to fail, confirm the dollar cap — Old Republic stops at $6,500 per system.
- Do you want a fixed tier or a matched plan? Old Republic uses Basic, Deluxe, and Elite; Empire Home Protect matches coverage to your systems and appliances.
- What service fee fits your budget? A higher fee usually lowers your monthly premium with either provider.
For a side-by-side at the plan level, see our dedicated Empire Home Protect vs Old Republic comparison page, and check the best home warranty companies of 2026 rankings to see how both measure up against the wider market.
Reading the Fine Print on Either Plan
Fine print is the set of coverage limits, exclusions, and service terms that determine whether a specific breakdown is paid. Both Empire Home Protect and Old Republic Home Protection publish a contract that lists what is covered, the dollar caps, and the exclusions, so read it before you buy. Pay attention to pre-existing conditions, maintenance requirements, and per-item caps, which shape most denied claims. Reviews and complaint histories are also worth a look — the Better Business Bureau publishes complaint records for home warranty companies, including Old Republic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Empire Home Protect available in more states than Old Republic?
Yes. Empire Home Protect offers home warranty coverage to homeowners across the United States, while Old Republic Home Protection sells its plans in 25 states plus Washington, D.C. If your home is outside Old Republic’s footprint, Empire Home Protect is the available option.
How much does Old Republic Home Protection cost in 2026?
Old Republic’s three tiers run roughly $45 to $90 per month based on 2026 quotes: Basic is $45 to $55, Deluxe is $55 to $70, and Elite is $70 to $90. Each claim carries a service fee of $100 or $125, and a full year can be paid over three months.
What are Old Republic’s coverage caps?
Old Republic caps heating at $6,500 and air conditioning at $6,500. Appliances are capped at $3,500 per item on the Basic and Deluxe plans or $7,000 on Elite. Interior electrical and general plumbing carry no stated dollar limit.
Do both companies guarantee their repairs?
Yes. Both Empire Home Protect and Old Republic Home Protection back completed covered repairs for 30 days. If the same covered problem returns within that window, you should not pay a second service fee for the follow-up visit.
How do I choose between the two?
Start with availability, then compare caps, service fees, and plan structure against your home’s age and systems. Get a quote from each provider for your address, read the contract’s exclusions, and pick the plan whose caps cover your most failure-prone systems.
The Bottom Line
Old Republic Home Protection is an established home warranty company with three clear tiers, but it sells in only 25 states plus D.C. and caps HVAC at $6,500. Empire Home Protect offers coverage to homeowners across the United States with plans matched to your home. Compare the caps, fees, and availability that apply to your address, then protect your budget from surprise repair bills. Get your free Empire Home Protect quote today and see exactly what your plan covers.
Related Articles
- Empire Home Protect vs American Home Shield (2026)
- Empire Home Protect vs Choice Home Warranty (2026)
- How to Choose a Home Warranty Company: Buyer’s Guide
- Home Warranty Plan Types Explained: A Buyer’s Guide
