Empire Home Protect vs AFC Home Club (2026 Comparison)

Reading Progress:

Empire Home Protect vs AFC Home Club (2026 Comparison)

Key Takeaways

  • Empire Home Protect offers nationwide coverage for major home systems and appliances with a personalized quote for your home.
  • AFC Home Club is known for letting members use their own approved licensed technician and for one of the longest workmanship guarantees in the industry.
  • Third-party reviews report AFC Home Club serves 47 states, excluding California, Hawaii, and Washington; Empire Home Protect covers homeowners nationwide.
  • Both companies charge a per-visit service fee; AFC lists $75, $100, and $125 options, while Empire pricing is set by a custom quote.
  • The best plan depends on whether technician choice, price, or a single nationwide point of contact matters most to you.

Comparing Empire Home Protect vs AFC Home Club comes down to three things in 2026: how each plan is priced, who handles your covered repairs, and where each company operates. Empire Home Protect provides nationwide coverage for major systems and appliances and sets your price with a custom quote, while AFC Home Club (formerly America’s First Choice Home Club) is best known for letting members pick their own approved technician and for a workmanship guarantee it describes as the longest in the industry. This guide breaks down coverage, cost, and service so you can decide which fits your home.

Empire Home Protect vs AFC Home Club: how do they compare?

Empire Home Protect and AFC Home Club are both home warranty providers that help cover the repair or replacement of major systems and appliances when they fail from normal wear and tear. They differ most in how repairs are routed, how plans are priced, and how many states each serves. The table below summarizes the key decision factors.

Factor Empire Home Protect AFC Home Club
Coverage scope Major home systems and appliances across plan tiers Appliance-only up to full systems-and-appliance plans (Silver, Gold, Platinum, Diamond)
Who performs repairs Coverage is provided; covered repairs are carried out by independent, licensed service technicians Members may use their own licensed technician, subject to AFC approval of the diagnosis and cost
Workmanship guarantee Covered repairs backed per your plan terms Marketed as the longest in the industry (reviews cite up to the life of the plan)
Service fee Set in your quote $75, $100, or $125 per visit (lower fee raises the monthly premium)
Availability Nationwide 47 states (not California, Hawaii, or Washington), per third-party reviews
Pricing method Custom quote by home and plan Published monthly tiers plus add-ons

What does each company cover?

Home warranty coverage is organized into plan tiers that add more systems and appliances as you move up. Both companies protect the items most homeowners worry about — heating, cooling, plumbing, electrical, and kitchen and laundry appliances — with the exact list set by the plan you choose and your written contract.

  • Appliances: refrigerators, ranges and ovens, dishwashers, built-in microwaves, washers, dryers, and garbage disposals on appliance or combination plans.
  • Systems: heating, air conditioning, ductwork, electrical, and plumbing on systems or combination plans.
  • Add-ons: optional items such as pool and spa equipment, stand-alone freezers, sump pumps, septic systems, and well pumps for an extra annual charge.
  • Coverage caps: both providers apply per-item dollar limits and exclude pre-existing conditions and improper maintenance, so read the contract caps before you buy.

Empire Home Protect publishes its current plan options so you can match coverage to your home’s age and systems.

How much does each home warranty cost in 2026?

Home warranty cost is the sum of a recurring premium plus a service fee charged each time a technician visits. AFC Home Club premiums reported by independent reviewers range from roughly the mid-$30s a month for appliance-only coverage to more than $120 a month for its top Diamond tier, plus a $75, $100, or $125 service fee per visit. Empire Home Protect sets pricing by your home and plan, so the most accurate number comes from a custom quote.

When you compare prices, weigh the premium against the service fee together. A plan with a low monthly premium but a high per-visit fee can cost more over a year if you file several claims, while a slightly higher premium with a lower service fee can be cheaper for an older home that needs frequent repairs. For a deeper breakdown, see our guide to home warranty cost by plan type and our 2026 home warranty rankings. Industry reviewers such as This Old House and SeniorLiving.org publish current AFC pricing and ratings.

Which home warranty is right for you?

The right home warranty is the one whose coverage, price, and service model match how you want repairs handled. Use these steps to narrow the decision between Empire Home Protect and AFC Home Club.

  1. List your most valuable systems and appliances, then confirm each is named in the plan tier you are considering.
  2. Decide whether choosing your own technician matters to you or whether you prefer a single company to coordinate the repair.
  3. Add the annual premium and your likely number of service-fee visits to compare true yearly cost, not just the monthly price.
  4. Check availability for your ZIP code, since AFC does not serve California, Hawaii, or Washington.
  5. Read the coverage caps and exclusions, then request a quote so you are comparing real numbers for your home.

How to get a quote from Empire Home Protect

Getting an Empire Home Protect quote takes a few minutes and gives you an exact price to compare against AFC Home Club’s published tiers. Coverage is provided by Empire Home Protect, and a covered repair is carried out by an independent, licensed service technician.

  1. Visit the quote page and enter your home details.
  2. Choose the plan tier that covers your priority systems and appliances.
  3. Review the premium, service fee, and coverage caps in your contract before you enroll.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Empire Home Protect or AFC Home Club better in 2026?

Neither is better for every homeowner. Empire Home Protect offers nationwide coverage for major systems and appliances with a personalized quote, while AFC Home Club is known for letting members pick their own licensed technician (with approval) and a long workmanship guarantee. The right choice depends on which features and price matter most to you.

Does AFC Home Club let you choose your own technician?

Yes. AFC Home Club lets members request their own licensed technician, but the company must approve the technician and the diagnosis before work begins. Empire Home Protect coordinates covered repairs through its own network of independent, licensed service technicians.

What states does AFC Home Club cover?

Third-party reviews report that AFC Home Club serves 47 states and does not operate in California, Hawaii, or Washington. Empire Home Protect provides coverage to homeowners nationwide, so availability is worth confirming for your ZIP code before you buy.

How much does a home warranty cost with each company?

AFC Home Club premiums reported by review sites range from roughly the mid-$30s a month for appliance-only plans to over $120 a month for its top tier, plus a $75, $100, or $125 service fee. Empire Home Protect pricing depends on your home and plan, so request a custom quote for an exact figure.

Do both companies charge a service fee per claim?

Yes. A per-visit service fee is standard across the home warranty industry. AFC Home Club lists $75, $100, and $125 options, where a lower fee means a higher monthly premium. Confirm Empire Home Protect’s current service fee when you request your quote.

Is there a waiting period before coverage starts?

A 30-day waiting period after enrollment is common in the industry, and AFC Home Club applies one (waived for qualifying new-home purchases with a valid inspection). Review your Empire Home Protect contract for its exact start date and any waiting period that applies.

Protect your home with Empire Home Protect

Ready to compare real numbers? Explore Empire Home Protect plans or get your free custom quote today and see how nationwide coverage for your major systems and appliances stacks up against the alternatives.

Related Articles

GET QUOTE CALL NOW